What makes an arrangement a sharing ministry

Federal law has one definition. In 26 U.S.C. 5000A(d)(2)(B)(ii), a health care sharing ministry means an organization that meets five conditions. It must be described in section 501(c)(3) and exempt from tax. Its members must share a common set of ethical or religious beliefs and share medical expenses among members in accordance with those beliefs, without regard to the state where a member lives or works. Members must retain membership even after they develop a medical condition. It, or a predecessor, must have existed at all times since December 31, 1999, with medical expenses shared continuously since at least that date. And it must conduct an annual audit by an independent certified public accounting firm, made available to the public on request.

That definition sits in a section about the federal individual coverage requirement, so read it as a statement of what the statute says, not as a general licence. States set their own rules. Colorado requires sharing arrangements to report to its Division of Insurance each year, and Michigan’s regulator has reminded consumers that these ministries are not health insurance. Ask a program which state rules it says apply.

This guide is general information. Anyone thinking about forming a sharing program should talk to a qualified attorney. We do not give legal advice.

The member lifecycle

A program typically does the same few things in order. It takes an application, which often includes a statement of beliefs and health questions. It records the household, who is a member and who is a dependent. It sets up monthly contributions. And it publishes the guidelines that explain what may be shared.

Records matter at each step. A sharing decision months later depends on knowing who was a member on the date of service and which guidelines applied then. Some programs run these steps in a paper process or spreadsheets; others use software.

Processing a medical need

When a member submits a need, the program typically moves through these steps:

  1. Intake. The member or provider sends the bill and any records.
  2. Guideline review. The program checks eligibility, waiting-period and pre-existing condition rules, and duplicate bills.
  3. Provider bills arriving. Providers may send bills as standard electronic files.
  4. Repricing or negotiation. Some programs reduce or negotiate the amount. See repricing and balance bills.
  5. Explanation of sharing. The program tells the member what it did, line by line. See how to read an explanation of sharing.
  6. Appeals. The guidelines should say how a member can ask for another review.

Claimaro, a claims-software company related to this site, has an explainer of the 834, 835 and 837 file types that describes the claim file, the 837, as the electronic form of a provider bill.

Disclosure: Claimaro is a claims-administration software company under common ownership with Healthshare Compared. Its articles are written for organizations that run sharing programs and health plans, not for members, and some describe its own product. We link to it only where it explains a term used in this guide. It is not a recommendation of any program. How this site earns money.

None of this guarantees that a bill will be shared. The program decides under its guidelines. The member’s side of the process is described in what happens after you submit a medical bill.

Money and records

A program has to track several kinds of money. Monthly contributions come in. Eligible needs are shared out. Member responsibility amounts, where a program uses them, have to be tracked for each member. Providers have to be paid or negotiated with. Mistakes in these records show up as wrong balances, duplicated sharing or late answers.

The federal definition above also requires an annual audit by an independent certified public accounting firm, available to the public on request. Ask for it. Colorado’s reports page describes annual reporting of enrollment, finances and guidelines to its Division of Insurance, which shows what a state may ask a program to disclose.

Privacy matters because these records hold medical information. Ask how the program stores records, who can see them, and how long it keeps them. We do not need your medical details here, and you should not enter them on this site.

Questions a member can ask

  • Is the program a nonprofit, and where do I see its annual audit?
  • Which state rules does it say apply to it?
  • Where are the current written guidelines, and how are changes announced?
  • How long does it usually take to answer a sharing request, and is that in writing?
  • Who handles bills, and who talks to the provider?
  • How do repricing and negotiation work, and what happens if the provider does not agree?
  • How do I ask for a review of a decision?
  • How are my medical records stored and shared?

The Colorado Division of Insurance’s consumer advisory cautions people about the limits of sharing programs and is a useful read before joining any of them.

Next step

Read what health sharing is if you are new to the idea, and how to compare healthshares for a checklist you can use with the questions above. Our comparison page lists programs side by side. Health sharing is not insurance, and payment of medical expenses is not guaranteed.