Billed, eligible, shared: three numbers
Almost every healthshare bill involves three different amounts.
- Billed is what the provider charged.
- Eligible is the amount the program treats as eligible for sharing under its guidelines. It can be lower than the billed amount.
- Shared is what the program shares. Depending on the guidelines, it may be the eligible amount minus your member responsibility and any lines the guidelines do not allow.
Insurance has similar words. HealthCare.gov defines the allowed amount as the maximum amount a plan will pay for a covered health care service, and defines UCR as the amount paid for a service in a geographic area based on what providers there usually charge. The same page says a UCR amount is sometimes used to determine the allowed amount. A sharing program’s eligible amount is set by its own guidelines, so use these definitions to understand the idea, not to predict the number.
Why there is often no network contract
With insurance, an in-network provider has agreed to accept the allowed amount. A sharing program may work differently. It may use a network, a pricing vendor, negotiation after the fact, or none of these. Which one applies is a question for the guidelines, and different programs answer it differently. Ask the program in writing.
What reference-based pricing means
Reference-based pricing sets an eligible amount from a public benchmark rather than from a negotiated contract. The provider has not necessarily agreed to accept that number.
Claimaro, a claims-software company related to this site, has a worked example of reference-based pricing written for health plans; the arithmetic is the same idea, but a sharing program’s guidelines set the real rule.
Disclosure: Claimaro is a claims-administration software company under common ownership with Healthshare Compared. Its articles are written for organizations that run sharing programs and health plans, not for members, and some describe its own product. We link to it only where it explains a term used in this guide. It is not a recommendation of any program. How this site earns money.
Where a balance bill comes from
HealthCare.gov defines balance billing with an example: if the allowed amount is $70 and the provider charged $100, the provider may bill you for the remaining $30. The idea is the same in health sharing. When the provider has not agreed to accept the eligible amount, the provider may still bill you for the gap.
Its glossary also explains why balance billing happens when no contract binds the provider.
A made-up example
Illustrative numbers only. They are not any program’s amounts.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Provider billed | $10,000 |
| Program treats as eligible | $6,000 |
| Member responsibility | $1,000 |
| Shared, if the guidelines allow | $5,000 |
| Gap the provider could still bill | $4,000 |
In this example the $4,000 gap sits between the billed and eligible amounts. Who is responsible for it depends on the provider and on the program’s written process. A program may describe steps for talking to the provider, or it may leave that to you. Find out which before care, not after.
What federal protections do and do not say
CMS says the No Surprises Act applies to most types of health insurance and protects you from unexpected out-of-network bills in specific situations, such as emergency room visits. It also says that if you do not have or use health insurance, providers usually must give you a good faith estimate of what your care will cost if you request one or schedule services at least 3 business days in advance. CMS explains what a good faith estimate is on a separate page.
This guide does not say how those rules apply to a healthshare member. Ask the provider and the program how your visit is classed, and keep the answer in writing.
Questions to ask before care
- Does the program negotiate or reprice bills, and when in the process?
- Who talks to the provider, you or the program?
- What happens if the provider will not accept the repriced amount?
- Is any help for that situation described in writing?
- Does the provider offer a self-pay discount?
- Can I get a good faith estimate before the visit?
- Can I get an itemized bill afterwards?
If a balance bill arrives
Do not ignore it. Ask for an itemized bill and compare it with the statement from the program. Send the bill to the program and ask what the guidelines say about it. Ask the provider about financial assistance and payment options. The CFPB advises checking for protections under federal and state law and financial assistance you may be entitled to. Our guide to reading an explanation of sharing helps you match each line.
Next step
Read what happens after you submit a medical bill and what a healthshare really costs. Our comparison page lists programs side by side. This is general information, not legal advice.