The short answer
It depends on the guidelines of the specific program and membership option, so do not assume. Health sharing is not insurance, and the NAIC says payment of medical expenses through a sharing ministry is not guaranteed. Medication is where that difference is easiest to feel, because you may need it every month for years.
This guide does not say what any program shares. It lists what to look for and how to budget while you wait for an answer.
How insurance handles prescriptions
HealthCare.gov lists prescription drugs among the essential health benefits that Marketplace plans cover. It also explains that a plan helps pay for certain medications, and that medications on the plan’s formulary, its approved list, usually cost you less. HealthCare.gov defines a formulary as a list of prescription drugs covered by a prescription drug plan or another insurance plan. Those are insurance rules. A healthshare has no formulary unless its guidelines describe something like one.
What guidelines may say
A program may use any of these patterns, or none. Each is a question, not a statement about any program.
- Medication may be tied to an eligible need, so a prescription tied to an ongoing condition is read together with the pre-existing condition rules. See our pre-existing conditions guide.
- Sharing for medication may be time-limited, for example for a short course after an event.
- Maintenance medication, taken long term, may be treated differently from medication for a short episode.
- A separate discount or pharmacy service may sit beside the membership.
Discount cards are not sharing
A discount program lowers a price. It does not share a cost. If a membership includes a prescription discount, find out who provides it and under what agreement, as our cost worksheet advises for every add-on. Ask whether it is required, what it costs on its own and whether it ends if you leave the membership.
A discount price is not the same as a shared amount. Record the two in separate columns.
Budget for a medication year
Ask the pharmacy for the cash price of each prescription you take, and ask whether the price is for a 30-day or a 90-day supply.
Illustrative numbers only. They are not any program’s amounts.
| Medication type | Monthly cash price you were quoted | Shared? |
|---|---|---|
| Daily maintenance tablet | $40 | Unknown until the program replies |
| Short antibiotic course | $20, once | Unknown |
| Specialty medication | $900 | Unknown |
In this fictional case, if none of it were shared, a year would cost $480 for the tablet alone, and $10,800 for the specialty medication. Keep “unknown” in the table until the program answers in writing. Do not budget for a sharing outcome you have not confirmed.
Ask the pharmacy for numbers
Programs can answer only what they are asked, and a pharmacy can answer a different set of questions. Ask the pharmacy for the cash price of each prescription, whether it is for a 30-day or a 90-day supply, and whether the price changes with the pharmacy you use. Write down the date you were quoted; prices move. Ask your prescriber whether a lower-cost alternative exists, and let the prescriber decide whether it suits you.
Then give the program the same list. Ask it to point to the section of the guidelines that decides each item, rather than telling you in general terms that medication is or is not shared.
When the answer is no
If the guidelines do not share a medication you take, you still have decisions to make. Compare the monthly cash price with your budget, ask the prescriber about options, and check whether an insurance route changes the picture: HealthCare.gov says Marketplace plans help pay for prescriptions, and a plan’s formulary shows which medications it lists. Compare insurance on its own terms, with your actual medication list, using the official site. See health sharing versus insurance.
Questions to ask
- Where do the guidelines address prescription medication?
- Is maintenance medication treated differently from short-term medication?
- Does a pre-existing condition rule apply to a medication I take now?
- Is there a limit, a waiting period or a member responsibility for medication, and what unit does it use?
- Is a discount or pharmacy service included, optional or separate, and who provides it?
- Can the answer be given in writing, with the section and guideline date?
Talk to your prescriber first
Never stop, skip or switch a medication because of cost research. Ask your prescriber or pharmacist about options, including whether a different supply size or alternative exists, before you change anything. This is not medical advice.
Next step
Read routine and preventive care with a healthshare and the guide to waiting periods and sharing limits, then use the comparison page to keep your notes side by side.